ButcherBox vs Good Ranchers: Whis is The Best Meat and Seafood Subscription Service in 2024?

By Insider Envy Staff

Subscription meat and seafood delivery services like ButcherBox are changing the game for home cooks and health-conscious folks across the US. ButcherBox, which started in 2015 with support from a Kickstarter campaign, has become the go-to choice for 1.5 million members. They’re known for their top-quality meat and seafood, which many people trust because they only partner with farms that meet high animal welfare standards. This means their products are not only tasty but also sourced in a sustainable way. Good Ranchers is another competing subscription meat delivery service which was founded in 2018. Can Good Ranchers beat ButcherBox as the best meat and seafood subscription service of 2024?

Let’s look into which service is best for your needs:

Quality: ButcherBox shines where it matters most

ButcherBox and Good Ranchers both focus on quality meat, but ButcherBox is the winner in some key ways. ButcherBox is one of the only companies in the space which is B-corp certified, meaning all the farms and fisheries they partner with have to follow very high standards. They offer 100% grass-fed beef, organic chicken, heritage pork, and wild-caught seafood all without added hormones or antibiotics. Good Ranchers also aims for quality with heritage pork, chicken without added hormones or antibiotics, and wild-caught seafood. However, their beef is grass-fed and grain-finished, not 100% grass-fed like ButcherBox’s.

Plan Flexibility: Way more options with ButcherBox

ButcherBox is the clear choice for flexibility and lets you pick if you want a curated box or to customize your own delivery. Unlike Good Ranchers, ButcherBox has over 50 options to choose from and offers extra cuts and add-ons to round out your box.

Good Ranchers only has 14 pre-made boxes with different meat and seafood, so there are fewer choices.

Both services let you pick how often you get deliveries: every 4, 6, or 8 weeks. ButcherBox is even better because they also have an option for every 2 weeks, and they let you choose which day of the week you get your delivery.

Price: the most value for your dollar

When it comes to pricing, ButcherBox offers the best deal. Let’s compare the numbers: Good Ranchers’ most popular Ranchers Classic box gives you 9.9-10.5 lbs of meat for $194, which costs about $18.50 – $20 per pound. ButcherBox’s custom box with similar cuts costs $169 for 12.25 lbs of meat, which is $13.80 per pound.

ButcherBox sweetens the deal with frequent promotions, often adding a free cut to every box, lowering the cost to as little as $11.86 per pound. Plus, ButcherBox members can also get extra promotions each month to use on their next box.

ButcherBox emerges as the clear winner

In the battle of ButcherBox vs.Good Ranchers, ButcherBox is the clear winner. If you’re looking for top-notch meat and seafood, flexibility in your subscription, and a good deal—all from a company that cares about where your food comes from—ButcherBox is the way to go. It’s like having a gourmet butcher shop right at your fingertips, ready to deliver deliciousness straight to your door.

At Insider Envy we only promote products we love and want to let you know that while we participate in a number of affiliate programs, (meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on Insider Envy), we do not base our reviews on whether or not we receive compensation. Additionally, these fees do not affect the prices you pay for products and services listed on Insider Envy. We appreciate your support!

by Insider Envy Staff